I spend a lot of time reading, so I figured I’d discuss how I decide what to read.
Framework
Reading is a leisure activity for me (even if I choose to read something work-related), and my selections should reflect that. Otherwise, I might considering the following:
Is it recommended and by whom?
The easiest way to source a good book is from a trusted source – this could be from a podcast, a blog, or a conversation. Be wary of recommendations from friends, coworkers, and family, as tastes and motivations differ; the expanse of the internet is more effective at surfacing high quality (in the eyes of the reader) books.
The sweet spot is a book that has been recommended by multiple trusted sources.
When was it published? Are there copies available at the library?
Books that are popular well after their publishing are Lindy. For some reason, “top sellers” don’t seem to pass the test of time.
What has the popular reaction been?
Goodreads, Amazon, Google, and blogs leverage the wisdom of crowds and are, therefore, less biased relative to the perspective of one journalist.
Is it relevant to something that I want to learn? Am I generally curious in the top?
An obvious question, but one that bears articulating. Reading everything is not possible, and tradeoffs must be made. Do not read books because others want you to. Do it for yourself.
Is it worth a re-read?
As Nassim Nicholas Taleb says, and I tend to agree with: “Any book not worth rereading isn’t worth reading.” While you won’t know this up-front, you can still formulate a hypothesis. The exception is what I would call “guilty fiction,” which is purely meant for funsies (reminder: reading is about leisure!).
Memory Consolidation & Synthesis
I used to put down books as soon as I finished them. For some books, this is fine. But, for most, extra reflection is beneficial.
I’m currently iterating through what works for me. Initially I started with Googling to see what else had been written on the subject, which I found too passive and too easy to skip.
I then took to Twitter. The issue is that even great books can improve; as soon as this is articulated on Twitter, you are becoming critical of another person’s livelihood, potentially unfairly. That’s not within the scope of my remit.
Re-reading has become my favorite form of reflection. First, repetition leads to memory consolidation. And second, while the content of books may remain fixed, my perspective is dynamic. Catcher in the Rye is a good example. Through the lens of my 16-year-old self, Holden was an annoying, whiney little b*tch. Yet, as I get older, I am more compassionate to and understanding of him; our teenage years were universally challenging.
A final idea that I got from James Clear is to answer the below questions. Of course, these questions are more tailored to non-fiction books. I’ve decided to do that below for two books that I recently finished:
- What are the main ideas?
- If I implemented one idea from this book right now, which one would it be?
- How would I describe the book to a friend?
Trillion Dollar Coach
- An overview of the principles that made Bill Campbell impactful, including: the importance of radical candor, cheerleading, meritocracy, equality and how once the ego, human, and team “stuff” are addressed, the business “stuff” takes care of itself.
- This is an abstraction from the book, but: “In any situation, how would your 5-year-old self expect you to act?” (i.e., in any situation, how can you act without ego?)
- This book is a common sense set of principles of how to be a leader – it’s a good reminder that common sense is not the same as common practice
Overall Rating: I’ve now read this twice and will read it again
Status Anxiety
- Status anxiety is a given, but its causes and manifestations evolve as society evolves
- Meditate and reflect on if and why status anxiety might be present
- A systematic overview of the causes and solutions of status anxiety (i.e., having anxiety about ones’ “place” in society has)
Overall Rating: Compelling content albeit not very engaging, will probably just read a sparknotes-esque summary if I want to re-visit.